Greenwich.co.uk

Greenwich news and information

  • News
  • Sport
  • Blogs
  • Hotels
    • Serviced Apartments in Greenwich
  • Visiting
    • Things to Do in Greenwich
  • Greenwich Books
  • Collectibles
  • Transport Live

Alex Wilson: Why I’m voting no to AV

April 26, 2011 By Alex Wilson

On 5 May the UK will go to the polls for our first nationwide referendum for 36 years. We are being asked whether we want to get rid of our current voting system (sometimes referred to as ‘First Past the Post’) and replace it with a different system called the ‘Alternative Vote’ (AV).

This referendum is being held because it was one of the things Nick Clegg and the Liberal Democrats demanded in return for their part in forming the coalition government. The Lib Dems will be campaigning for a ‘Yes’ vote in the referendum and a change to AV – while the Conservatives, along with over 100 Labour MPs, hundreds of Labour councillors, and a number of trade unions, are backing the cross-party campaign for a ‘No’ vote to keep our current system. Here are some of the reasons why:

  • AV is unfair. For generations, our elections are based on the fundamental principle of ‘One Person, One Vote.’ AV would undermine that, allowing the supporters of fringe or extremist parties to have their vote counted five or six times – and potentially decide the outcome of the election – while people who backed the mainstream candidates only get one vote.
  • AV is unwanted. Even the Yes campaigners don’t really want AV. Before the general election, Nick Clegg described AV as ‘a miserable little compromise’. Another senior Lib Dem, Chris Huhne, said that ‘it does not give voters real power’. Now they want it because it will help their party hold the balance of power.
  • AV is obscure. Only three countries in the world use AV for their national elections: Fiji, Australia, and Papua New Guinea. Fiji have plans to get rid of it, and in Australia, 6 out of 10 voters want to return to the British system.
  • AV is expensive. Holding this referendum is costing the country £90 million, and AV itself would make elections more expensive. Counting the votes would take much longer, either by hand or on costly new electronic counting machines – and local taxpayers would end up footing the bill.

As a case in point if last year’s general election had been held under AV, there would have been at least four rounds of counting before one candidate got over 50% of the vote in the Greenwich & Woolwich constituency.

That means the 65 voters who voted for the least popular candidate would have had at least 4 votes, and the 267 people who voted for the Trade Union and Socialist Coalition candidate would have had at least 3 votes.

But the 9 out of 10 mainstream voters who voted for the Labour, Conservative or Liberal Democrat candidates would have had their votes counted just once.

Please vote to defend our system of One Person, One vote, by voting ‘No’ on 5 May.

Alex Wilson is a councillor representing the Blackheath Westcombe ward and has been selected as the Conservative’s London Assembly candidate for Greenwich and Lewisham.

Filed Under: Magazine Tagged With: AV Referendum

GREENWICH.CO.UK

Transport Updates

Current alerts and upcoming engineering works

TfL live data

Service disruptions

DLR — Part Closure

DOCKLANDS LIGHT RAILWAY: Saturday 21 and Sunday 22 November, no service between Canning Town and Stratford International. Please use JUBILEE LINE and local London Buses services.

Elizabeth line — Reduced Service

ELIZABETH LINE: Sunday 22 November, from 0740, a reduced service operates between Paddington and Heathrow Terminal 4 / Maidenhead. Two trains an hour serve West Drayton, Langley, Slough, Burnham and Maidenhead. Four trains an hour serve Heathrow Terminals 2 and 3. Eight trains an hour serve Ealing Broadway, Southall and Hayes & Harlington.

Upcoming planned works Next 14 days

Jubilee — Planned ClosureThu 26 Nov, 13:00 – Fri 27 Nov, 12:59

TUBE STRIKE: Some London Underground Tube drivers are planning to take strike action from 12:00 Thursday 26 until 11:59 Friday 27 November. There is likely to be some disruption across all Underground lines, but trains are expected to run on most lines.

Elizabeth line — Part ClosureSat 28 Nov, 05:30 – Mon 30 Nov, 02:29

ELIZABETH LINE: Saturday 28 and Sunday 29 November, no service between Maidenhead / Heathrow (all terminals) and Abbey Wood / Shenfield. Use PICCADILLY LINE services between Heathrow and Central London. LONDON PADDINGTON STATION will be closed on this day, with no HEATHROW EXPRESS services. GWR services will not run between Maidenhead / Greenford and Paddington, with limited long distance services to/from Euston. There will also be no GREATER ANGLIA services on these days between Shenfield / Southend Victoria / Southminster and Liverpool Street, use CENTRAL LINE connections between Ealing Broadway, West Acton (for Acton Main Line), Central London, Liverpool Street, Stratford and Newbury Park. Replacement bus services operate, not serving Iver, please use Langley instead.

View full transport information →
Powered by Transport for London open data. Predictions are estimates.

Recent Posts

  • Kevin Nolan’s Match Report: Charlton v Chelsea U-21 (29/10/24)
  • Kevin Nolan’s Match Report: Barnsley v Charlton (22/10/24)
  • Kevin Nolan’s Match Report: Bristol Rovers v Charlton (1/10/24)
  • Kevin Nolan’s Match Report: Cambridge United v Charlton (17/09/24)

Greenwich.co.uk © Uretopia Limited | About/Contact | Privacy Policy