Charlton 1 (Pratley 12) QPR 0

By a nerve-wracked Kevin Nolan and his equally stressed computer.

A second post-lockdown 1-0 victory boosted Charlton's hopes of avoiding immediate relegation back to League One, from the horrors of which they were delivered a year ago at Wembley. Both performances were similar, each hinging on an early setpiece goal which hindsight, with its usual wise-after-the-event cockiness, assures us was capably defended but during which identically unpleasant, tension-charged second halves reduced sofa-bound fans to gibbering wrecks.

If the Addicks stave off relegation, the depleted squad responsible for reaching the promised land will be remembered with affection and gratitude by their fearful fans. Making light of the defection of a talented top scorer, whose name is now irrelevant, and of lesser importance the disloyalty of Chris Solly and David Davis, they have bonded in the club's interest and have given themselves every chance of making it to safety. There are tough tests still ahead but you'd be wise not to bet against them.
Scorers of Charlton's vital goals were a pair of grizzled veterans who have, as they say, been around the block once or twice and seen a thing or two on the way. The manner in which defender Jason Pearce risked life and limb to bully home Tomas Hemed's backheader at Hull was typical of the skipper's unstinting commitment. Pearce has his detractors but while he continues to put up, they need to shut up.

Defensive midfield stalwart Darren Pratley doesn't score often but his goals tend to be important ones. His quick response to Doncaster Rovers' third goal in last season's semi-final second leg set up the penalty shoot-out which booked the Addicks' place at Wembley. This matchwinner against QPR saw him tower above a posse of hooped defenders and direct a forceful downward header from Josh Cullen's outswinging corner off Liam Kelly's left hand and in off the right-hand post. Like Pearce, Pratley's goal topped off another yeoman personal contribution.

With their 12th minute opener to defend, the home heroes set about the task with impressive discipline and calmness. Alongside Pearce, Tom Lockyer was outstanding, as were coldly efficient full backs in man-of-the match Adam Matthews and Deji Oshilaja. In midfield, Cullen put in his customary all-round shift and Albie Morgan continued his dramatic improvement since the Championship resumed. At wide right midfield, Aidan McGeady provided a useful outlet but was eclipsed by the all-action impact of his 60th minute replacement Alfie Doughty. who may well start at Cardiff on Tuesday. Doughty's timely introduction relieved the modest pressure and might have brought him a welcome clinching goal. This kid's a livewire prospect.

Faced by opponents happy to allow them possession up to a mutually agreed point, then allowing them no further in obdurate ranks of four, Rangers advanced, hesitated, square-passed meaninglessly and petered out. A first half of huffing, puffing and generally aimless pottering about produced only Ebere Eze's perilously curling shot which passed uncomfortably close to Dillon Phillips' right post. Meanwhile, the Addicks threatened to double their lead when Macauley Bonne ran on to Morgan's perceptive pass, shot fiercely from a diminishing angle on the left but was denied by Kelly's alert near post save

A minute after the interval, in creating and squandering their solitary clearcut chance, the visitors caused temperatures to rise collectively in living rooms clear across the Southland. Presented with a point blank "certainty" by Angel Rangel's clever delivery, Jordan Hugill applied the routine finishing touch and was already planning his celebration until Phillips, making astounding ground along his goalline, blocked his shot. Pratley's goal settled this vital game; Phillips' incredible save made sure it did.

Almost inured to last gasp sickeners this season, Charlton's absentee fans still feared the worst but were in good hands. Even the grisly prospect of five added minutes caused barely a ripple of inconvenience inside an eerily resonant Valley where Pearce and his defiant cohorts dispassionately stood their ground. Mark Warburton's vanquished West Londoners had been handed a lesson in thrifty use of meagre resources. Mind you, the security of a second goal wouldn't go unnoticed, if only to increase the life expectancy among the Addicks' played out, locked out, worn out supporter.

Charlton: Phillips, Matthews, Lockyer, Pearce, Oshilaja (Purrington76), McGeady (Doughty 60), Cullen, Pratley, Morgan (Field 84), Bonne (Green 84), Hemed (Aneke 60). Not used: Amos, Sarr, Williams, Davison. Booked: Pratley

QPR: Kelly, Manning, Barbet, Masterson, Rangel (Kane 71), Cameron (Amos 71), Ball (Bettache 76), Eze, Chair (Shodipo 60), Osayi-Samuel (Oteh 71), Hugill. Not used: Lumley, Kakay, Gubbins, Clarke

Charlton 0 Middlesbrough 1 (McNair 17).

Kevin Nolan reports from The Valley.

Another costly error. Another failure to score. Another avoidable defeat, this one plunging Charlton, for the first time this season, into the relegation zone. The search for three teams worse than themselves isn't over but the air of desperation which spread through The Valley on Saturday suggests that self belief is in short supply.

The disastrous mistake which gifted Middlesbrough their winning goal followed the depressing format which has blighted this campaign, its most recent example being the gift presented to Huddersfield's Karlan Grant a week earlier which began a demoralising 4-0 rout. If there's a way of screwing up, Charlton will find one.

On this occasion, a Boro attack had foundered and the ball reached Ben Purrington safely upfield. Anxious to avoid confrontation, he attempted to find George Lapslie in support behind him but carelessly turned over possession to Rudy Gestede who promptly ran at a glacial defence. Gestede's squared pass was efficiently sidefooted past Dillon Phillips by Paddy McNair and the Addicks were already doomed to chase a lost cause.

There were, of course, other options available to Purrington, among them a safety-first approach currently frowned on by the modern game. Had he turned and put his laces through the ball, the moment might have passed unremarked but playing out from the back is now de rigeur. Charlton are nothing if not fashionable, with Phillips following the current trend of initiating pointless passing patterns which usually end up back at his feet and are then kicked long anyway into the heart of a defence given time to prepare.

On those occasions when the keeper sprinted to his 18-yard line to launch quick clearances into the channels, the Teesiders were less secure, with Lyle Taylor a persistent nuisance and Andre Green taking his cue alongside him. Defenders don't relish balls landing over their shoulders. That's not in the coaching manuals but it doesn't make it less true.

Before Boro's 17th minute matchwinner, Green had shown the way by breaking over the halfway line with a train of defenders in his wake. His excellent cross from the right was met by a straining Taylor, who was unable to keep his running volley on target. His "miss" was promptly put into painful context by McNair's cool finish. "It drives me mad after all we work on all week," lamented Lee Bowyer, "and the preparation just goes out the window. We were on top and then we just give them a goal. It's kid's stuff and last week was the same. We need men to stand up and fight."

Bowyer's distress was understandable but there is an alternative. To reduce the potential for defensive error, kybosh the building from the back rigmarole, get the ball through quickly to Taylor and Co. by way of eager midfielders like Josh Cullen and Jonny Williams, and play in the opposition's half as much as possible. There's enough pace and power in his team to trouble moderate sides like Middlesbrough and clearly faltering Hull City next Saturday. Start Taylor, Green and Macauley Bonne up front at KCOM Stadium and go for broke. If we're to go down, do it with a loud bang and not the acquiescent whimper we offer right now.

There were other chances for the Addicks, with Green's goalbound effort alertly blocked by Ryan Shotton and Dejan Stojanovic instictively parrying Green's fiercely struck drive. Deji Oshilaja headed Jonny Williams' cross straight at the debutant goalkeeper. In the second half, lively substitute Bonne's cross set up Darren Pratley to mangle a close range finish, while Bonne himself tamely flicked Taylor's low delivery into the Austrian keeper's hands.

But it was referee Stephen Martin's decision to book Taylor for simulation rather than award him the penalty he deserved for luring Harold Moukoudi into a rash tackle inside the area that rankled. The defender clearly clipped Taylor after being fooled by his sharp turn but Martin added the insult of a yellow card to the injury he inflicted by turning down his justified appeal for a spotkick.

None of which implies that Middlesbrough were anything but reasonably comfortable winners. Phillips contributed fine saves from Marcus Tavernier and Lewis Wing as the Northerners wasted time expertly, managed the second half shrewdly and completed a 1-0 league double over the Addicks. They inflicted a body blow, no getting away from that. But it ain't over, not yet it ain't. With Tom Lockyer back and Naby Sarr hopefully on his way, Charlton still have a shot at safety. It all begins again at Hull. See you there.

Charlton: Phillips, Matthews, Oshilaja, Pearce, Purrington (Hemed 83), Pratley, Green, Cullen, Lapslie (Bonne 46), Williams (Doughty 66), Taylor. Not used: Amos, McGeady, Amith, Davis. Booked: Matthews, Purrington, Taylor.

Boro: Stojanovic, Howson, Shotton, Moukoudi, Johnson, Clayton, McNair (Saville 81), Tavernier (Spence 87), Wing, Coulson, Gestede. Not used: Pears, Assombalonga, Fletcher, Morrison, Nmecha. Booked: Shotton.

Referee: Stephen Martin

Charlton 0 Blackburn Rovers 2 (Buckley 29, Adarabioyo 37).

Kevin Nolan reports from The Valley.

Like Storm Dennis which offered bluff and bluster but thankfully little carnage locally (so far), Charlton followed their firecracker win over Nottingham Forest with the damp squib of this tame, tepid defeat by cool Blackburn Rovers. Tony Mowbray's promotion outsiders handed the Addicks a lesson in calm, unemotional game management.

Never reluctant to tinker with a winning team, Lee Bowyer made just one, somewhat controversial change to the side which illuminated the City Ground. Despite playing his part manfully in midweek, diminutive Erhun Oztumer was possibly considered unsuited to Saturday's filthy conditions and unlikely to make a similar impression against Mowbray's physical Rovers. Fair enough but in his replacement Aiden McGeady, Bowyer hardly turned to a workaholic midfield hard man. McGeady's vague, jittery contribution failed to justify his decision to drop Oztumer.

Bowyer's dogged faith in Tomer Hemed is similarly difficult to understand. The strongly built Israeli tries hard but rarely looks likely to score. A goal would undoubtedly galvanise him - not to mention a patient crowd - but in five starts plus seven substitute appearances,  a breakthrough has looked unlikely. Either Andre Green (two goals) or the returning Macauley Bonne (eight goals) must surely start alongside Lyle Taylor in the crunch clash with Luton Town on Saturday. Both Green and Bonne featured on Saturday, significantly as replacements for Hemed and McGeady. Oztumer watched impassively from the bench.

Darren Pratley, if fit, should surely be considered ahead of David Davis, an apparent like-for-like but in fact a pale imitation of Charlton's inspirational on-field leader. Sadly, Pratley seems to have been disappeared to join Chris Solly, last seen in the Cup defeat by West Brom on January 5th, in a mythical Room 101 where discards are never seen again nor even discussed.

There was, to be fair, no lack of effort from Bowyer's choices but they were always second best to Mowbray's marauders. Following a bright start, during which both Taylor and Hemed drew competent saves from Christian Walton, Rovers asserted themselves. They were denied a fairly obvious penalty when Jason Pearce manhandled Dominic Samuel inside the area but moved into the lead within the opening half hour.Setting off on a solo dribble from left to right, with intelligent decoy running by Amari'i Bell in support beside him, winger John Buckley worked himself into a position from which to unleash a crisp drive which caught a useful deflection and left Dillon Phillips helpless on its way inside the keeper's right post.

Eight minutes later, the visitors doubled their lead with assistance from another of referee Andy Davies' eccentric decisions. It's taken for granted, of course, that players second guess referees even when caught holding a smoking gun but Davis' protest that his tackle on Buckley was legitimate had an earnest ring of truth about it. Davies was unmoved, however, leaving Stewart Downing to deliver a wickedly inswinging free kick which Tosin Adarbioyo turned in from six yards.

Before the interval, Taylor's athletically improvised header from Josh Cullen's cross was spectacularly tipped over the bar by Walton but Charlton's impact was minimal. Blackburn retired in good order with three points already securely in their grasp. Their sedate progress through an uneventful second half was uninterrupted by undue inconvenience, though it might have been interesting to discover where Hemed's close range header finished up had it not bounced harmlessly off an unaware defensive head into Walton's grateful hands. The keeper also parried Taylor's accurately struck free kick and repeated his earlier gymnastics to divert Cullen's powerful drive to safety, following Darragh Lenihan's crude foul on McGeady. But the two-goal deficit was otherwise comfortably protected.

Easily beaten by a better side, the Addicks will no doubt be encouraged to chalk this setback down to experience and move on. Next Saturday's visit from Luton Town now shapes up as this season's most crucial game, for which Bowyer's team selection will be critical. The Hatters have breathed life into their seemingly lost cause and will be no pushover. Is there such a thing in this crazy division?

Charlton: Phillips, Matthews, Lockyer, Pearce (Smith 46), Sarr, Doughty, Davis, Cullen, McGeady (Bonne 69), Taylor, Hemed (Green 60). Not used: Amos, Purrington, Oshilaja, Oztumer.

Blackburn: Walton, Nyambe, Lenihan, Adarabioyo, Bell, Travis, Johnson, Downing, Buckley (Bennett 84), Armstrong (Chapman, Samuel (Brereton 81). Not used: Leutwiler, Graham, Davenport, Carter. Booked: Nyambe, Bell, Lenihan, Buckley.

Referee: Andy Davies. Att: 25,363 (2083 visiting).

Charlton 0 Fulham 0.

Kevin Nolan reports from The Valley.

At a Valley with a new, buoyant spring in its step, well-organised Charlton frustrated promotion hopefuls Fulham, achieved their first clean sheet since October 15th and added a precious point to the total they need to ensure Championship safety. The game itself was no thing of beauty but provided a savage satisfaction of its own.

There were numerous, other reasons for optimism. The return of engine room maestro Josh Cullen to the starting line-up and the charismatic  presence of Lyle Taylor on the bench provided exactly the boost a threadbare squad needed to re-energise itself. Word is they will be joined soon by other long-term absentees.

The West Londoners, meanwhile, had injury problems of their own, all of them up front. They arrived, as expected, without clever bruiser Aleksandar Mitrovic and Brighton loanee Anthony Knockaert, who had scored their recent winner against Middlesbrough. Also unavailable was Aboubakar Kamara, Mitrovic's natural deputy, whose two goals beat QPR 2-1 two weeks ago. There was abundant skill in Fulham's line-up but an obvious lack of cutting edge.

The reinstatement in central defence of Jason Pearce was Lee Bowyer's solution to the worrying vulnerability which has regularly leaked goals and squandered leads. Pearce comes in for criticism from many keyboard experts but his spirit will be invaluable in the coming weeks. Always prone to at least one defensive bloodrush -the late free kick he conceded to Fulham here caused unpleasant heart murmurs - his captain's example more than compensates, a point made by his crucial second half block on Bobby DeCordova-Reid. The no-quarter battle of Charlton's Crazy Horse with Mitrovic at Craven Cottage in October is the stuff of legend.

After a three-month absence, Cullen took time to settle in but his influence is incalculable and his continuing good health vital. Typically he completed 90 minutes, by the end of which he was calling the shots again as the go-to midfielder. Taylor's 70th minute re-appearance, as replacement for hardworking Tomer Hemed, whose passionate appeal for a penalty when hauled down by Michael Hector was ignored by referee Stephen Martin, also lifted The Valley and helped see them over the line to a useful result. The encouraging performance was illuminated yet again by a sterling contribution from ageless Darren Pratley.  A full complement of Addicks, strengthened by one or two transfer window arrivals, has little to fear in this division.

Chances in a grimly contested game were few. Neat in their approach but playing harmlessly in front of Charlton's alert defence, the Cottagers made the majority of them and should have broken local hearts early in the second half. Upfield for a left wing corner, defender Michael Hector was unmarked at the far post when picked out by Ivan Cavaleiro's precise cross. The Chelsea loanee's free header was wastefully directed wide. In a tepid first half, Dillon Phillips made two smart saves from DeCordova-Reid, but was beaten by Joe Bryan's fierce low crosshot as it zipped dangerously wide of his left-hand post. In defence of his rare clean sheet, Phillips was relatively untroubled during an attritional second period.

Solid and determined, Charlton offered an occasional threat. Alfie Doughty's pace posed problems though his final ball was frequently wayward. Switched to the right flank in the second half, his clever cutback to Erhun Oztumer brought a wildly sliced effort from the diminutive fireball which flew high, wide and unhandsome on its way over Marek Rodak's crossbar. Doughty himself pounced on an error by a tetchy.  Harry Arter and forced a rare save from Rodak.

Pleased and proud of his warriors, Bowyer can now turn his attention to the massive encounter with Barnsley at The Valley on February 1st. His squad could be bolstered by recovered invalids and new blood while the Tykes face an inconvenient Cup trip to Portsmouth on Saturday, where Dickie Bird and Michael Parkinson are expected to start. Still with only one win in their last 17 league games, the green shoots of recovery, nurtured by the return to the colours of Cullen, Taylor and the effervescent Jonny Williams, are at last poking through. The treatment rooms at Sparrows Lane are beginning to empty. We're close to having our Charlton back...

Charlton: Phillips,Matthews, Lockyer, Pearce, Purrington, Pratley, Morgan (Williams 63), Cullen, Oztumer (Green 82), Doughty, Hemed (Taylor 70). Not used: Maynard-Brewer, Oshilaja, Sarr, Dempsey. Booked: Cullen.

Fulham: Rodak, Hector, Odoi, McDonald, Cairney (Johansen 77), Ream, DeCordova-Reid, Arter (Christie 72), Cavaleiro, Bryan, Onomah (Stansfield 88). Not used: Bettinelli, Kongolo,De la Torre, Sessegnon. Booked:Ream.

Referee: Stephen Martin. Att: 16,424 (2,337 visiting).

In memory of Barry Cawley -Richard's dad and dedicated Fulham fan - who died recently and whose funeral takes place next Tuesday 28th, 2020. Rest in Peace, Barry -  in the Premier League hopefully.

Derby County 2 (Knight 10,77) Charlton 1 (Taylor 83,pen)

Kevin Nolan reports from Pride Park.

The cracks in Lee Bowyer's constantly re-jigged squad are beginning to widen and threaten to become unmanageable. Their miserable failure to beat Derby despite the home side being reduced to 10 men for all but a quarter hour of this desperately disappointing game was ominous. The strain is starting to show, with the wretchedly ill-timed loss of Boxing Day hero Macauley Bonne to suspected hamstring damage  guaranteed to add another furrow to Bowyer's already fevered brow.

Bonne's magnificent two-goal performance which destroyed Bristol City inspired hope that with Lyle Taylor back in scoring form, the Addicks had at their disposal a strike force to match any in the division. Instead, Bonne now joins the panel of patients in the New Eltham dispensary while Taylor is still feeling his way back to full fitness. With the January transfer window supplying its usual mishmash of truth and fiction, we're likely to hear as much from their agents as Charlton's medical staff. Know what I'm saying?

Passive and timid, Charlton sleepwalked their way into this vital fixture. Less than a minute had elapsed when Jason Knight sent Martyn Waghorn sauntering through their dozing defence to confront Dillon Phillips. Practised and successful recently in these one-on-one duels, Phillips spread himself to save splendidly with his legs.

The visitors wilfully ignored the warning. Starting from a free kick rolled back to Tom Lockyer by Chris Solly, their passing from the back was ponderous and ill-conceived. As space became constricted, Naby Sarr's vague loss of possession allowed right back Andre Wisdom to cross from the touchline. A suspiciously offside Waghorn touched on for Knight to bravely head home at the far post despite Solly's earnest attempt to decapitate him. Charlton's catalogue of defensive errors continues to multiply.

Just five minutes after the goal, the Rams villainously compromised their bright start. The viciously late -and possibly premeditated - challenge launched by Krystian Bielik on regular target Conor Gallagher left referee Jeremy Simpson little alternative but to produce a red card. Moronically booed for his pains, Gallagher was mowed down again by Wisdom before the interval but Simpson remained unsympathetic on this occasion. Still only 19, the supremely talented Chelsea kid clearly has a price on his head. Widely popular during his successful loan spell at The Valley last season, Bielik was an out-of-character bounty hunter.

Their man-advantage failed to galvanise Bowyer's lethargic side. The best they mustered was Deji Oshilaja's routine header at an untroubled Ben Hamer and Bonne's weak effort over the bar. Bonne's obvious discomfort before the break saw him replaced by Taylor for the second half. That's the way it goes for the Addicks lately. As one door opens, another slams shut.

Taylor's neat lay-off for Gallagher to slice wildly over the bar began the second period promisingly enough. When Alfie Doughty drew a smart save from Hamer with a swerving shot, there was a further flicker of life but the Rams were hardly under siege. Jack Marriott broke through but missed the target woefully from the 18-yard line, then forced Phillips into a sharp save with a fiercely angled crosshot. But with 13 minutes left, Knight's second goal doubled the lead.

Loitering with intent to the right of goal as Duane Holmes fed Max Bird on the left, the young Ram was unchallenged as he volleyed his second senior goal from four yards. That was not quite that as Curtis Davies became the latest footpad to assault Gallagher, his offence carelessly committed inside the penalty area. Taylor duly reduced the arrears from the spot and Charlton briefly sensed a chance of redemption.

Hamer did his bit to preserve Derby's precious three points by brilliantly saving from substitute Ben Dempsey, then regaining his feet to smother Taylor's attempt to convert the rebound. An equaliser, while more than welcome, would have obscured the unvarnished truth that Charlton are in deep trouble, not altogether of their own making, but trouble nonetheless. Bowyer has been able to rely this season an unquenchable spirit in adversity. At Pride Park, that indispensable asset went missing. His side was listless, lethargic and ultimately lifeless. They need help. They need re-invigorating. They need new bloody owners!

Derby: Hamer, Wisdom, Davies, Clarke, Bird, Holmes, Bielik, Lowe, Knight, Marriott (Whittaker 90), Waghorn (Forsyth 90). Not used: Roos, Dowell, Martin, Sibley, Malone. Booked: Holmes.

Charlton: Phillips, Solly, Lockyer, Sarr (Davison 69), Purrington, Oshilaja (Dempsey 69), Pratley, Morgan, Gallagher, Bonne (Taylor 46), Doughty. Not used: Maynard-Brewer, Matthews, Pearce, Ledley. Booked: Gallagher, Pratley, Solly, Dempsey.

Att: 26,058). Referee: Jeremy Simpson.

Charlton 0 Huddersfield Town 1 (Daly 90+2).

Kevin Nolan reporting from the Valley

That comforting points gap which has consoled Charlton during their disastrous two-month slump is disappearing like (as my mum was fond of saying) the snow that fell last year. The Addicks are in freefall and no amount of reassurance that they'll be fine when their injured players return cuts the mustard. Despite their barnstorming start, this season was always about staying in the Championship, with 50 points the generally accepted minimum to aim at. Right now, they need 27 more points but if they continue to throw away useful draws, that total may turn out to be notional.

A grim, scoreless stand-off was clearly on offer when three unwanted added minutes were announced. Satisfied with their night's work, Huddersfield's body language made it obvious that they were ready to shake hands and call it off as sensible cricket teams do. A point's a point, no sense risking all three, was the message conveyed by their languid attitude to throw-ins and goal kicks.

Charlton had other ideas. Despite having failed to register a single effort on target, they fancied their chances of coming up with a late winner. For a few wild seconds, it seemed that Lyle Taylor had turned the trick but Naby Sarr was ruled offside before touching the ball on to his galvanic colleague. But there was a sting left in an awful game and the visitors were about to inflict the same painful misery on their victims as Bristol City and Millwall had recently.

From a free kick on the right, Junior Bacuna's delivery charted an uncertain course to the opposite flank, where Chris Solly was offered an opportunity to clear his lines on an anywhere-will-do basis. Instead his weak, left-footed squibber went straight to Florent Hadergjonaj, allowing the Swiss wide man to find Matt Daly inside him. The 18 year-old substitute swept his first-ever league goal, ironically enough, through Solly's legs into the far corner and the Addicks had yet again snatched defeat from the jaws of a perfectly acceptable draw. It's only fair to observe that Solly's solitary error marred an otherwise solid contribution from this ultimate team man. Next time though, Chris, put your laces through the bloody ball and send it to Kingdom Come. Nobody but the purists will blame you. Trust me.

There was precious little else to encourage beleaguered boss Lee Bowyer as he prepares for the potentially season-defining visit of Hull City on Friday evening. His team has adopted a jaded, threadbare look, which can only partly be explained by a catastrophic injury list. among which Josh Cullen's is the most sorely missed name. There is no lack of effort from the survivors but an understandable fear of making mistakes is unmanning them. Gone for the time being at least is the freewheeling, exuberant joy and cussed satisfaction they derived from defying pre-season predictions of their imminent downfall.  Bowyer's own decisions, meanwhile, such as his preference for greenhorn James Vennings over Albie Morgan as a replacement for a third novice in Alfie Doughty, seemed an almost perverse exercise of his authority and had the amateur tacticians scratching their heads. Young Vennings was probably not alone in being surprised by his manager's call.

Trawling through my meagre notes, meanwhile, I've failed to disinter so much as the whiff of a threat to Kamil Grabara's goal. Even when Solly ran dangerously on to Macauley Bonne's low cross intended for Taylor, his shot was capably blocked by Hadergjonaj. There was also, I believe, a first half shot from Doughty which whistled high and wide but that may be wishful thinking on my part. The Terriers were marginally more aggressive, with Dillon Phillips saving alertly from Karlan Grant and Josh Koroma early in the second half, not to mention Solly's razor-sharp interception to deny Grant an unhindered run on goal.

Shot-shy themselves, the Addicks fired popguns at their almost equally feeble visitors. It fell to an 18-year old Terrier to produce the marksmanship necessary to separate them and send Charlton slip-sliding into what certainly looks like a crisis. It feels like a crisis. Chances are it's a crisis. Yeah, it's a crisis.

Charlton: Phillips, Lockyer, Pearce, Sarr, Solly, Pratley, Gallagher, Purrington, Doughty (Vennings 73), Leko (Taylor 68), Bonne. Not used: Maynard-Brewer, Matthews, Oshilaja, Ledley, Morgan. Booked: Lockyer, Gallagher, Bonne.

Huddersfield: Grabara, Hogg, Bacuna, Kachunga, Koroma (Simpson 73), Schindler, Stankovic, Hadergjonaj, Mounie (Daly 76), Edmunds-Green, Grant. Not used: Coleman, Harratt, High, Austerfield, Jackson. Booked: Kachunga, Stankovic.

Referee: Graham Scott.. Att: 13,488 (680 visiting).

Millwall 2 (Hutchinson 6, Smith 90) Charlton (Leko 51)

Kevin Nolan reports from The Den.

The more things change, the more they stay the bloody same. There's a more stylish French saying which covers the subject without my sanguinary embellishment but let's stick with English to make the bleedin' point. It's reassuringly Anglo-Saxon.

Fact is there's things upon which you can depend as stone-cold certainties. You can rely, for example, on night following day; the seasons changing; the tides ebbing and flowing; the sun rising; the sun also setting; and Millwall beating Charlton. Or at least Millwall nearly always beating Charlton. There have, after all, been 27 draws among their 75 league meetings and - say it neither proud nor loud - 12 wins for the Addicks. The last of those victories was by 2-0 at The Valley on March 9th 1996, with current manager Lee Bowyer opening the scoring. Since that distant afternoon in a mothballed century, eleven more league games have been played; needless to say, Charlton have won none of them. To be fair, though, they drew five times.

A sixth draw looked likely when, with the score 1-1, three added minutes were announced at the Den on Saturday. On second thoughts, make that not so bloody likely! For among 2,211 Charlton fans in attendance and countless others following events through the media, you'd find hardly one of them who was genuinely surprised by what followed. Let's drag the French into it again and put it down to deja-vu. Yet again.

Having forced a left wing corner, the Lions loaded the goal area with hulking attackers. Among them was Matt Smith, called from the bench by Gary Rowett five minutes previously with this situation in mind. At 6'7", Smith is a rare handful at setpieces but in 6'5" man mountain Naby Sarr, Charlton had his physical match. Jed Wallace's expertly delivered inswinger duly targeted Smith at the far post, where the towering substitute swatted aside Sarr's powderpuff challenge and headed firmly past Dillon Phillips. There was scarcely any sense of shock in the upper tier of the stand behind the goal. Some colourful language, of course, but bitter experience soon reduced it to a sullen silence. It's happened too often to be dismissed as an unhappy accident.

An understandably seething Bowyer was scathing in his criticism of his players. As a museum piece member of a Charlton side which actually beat Millwall, he had history on his side when insisting that in defending setpieces, you "do your job and make sure your man doesn't score... coming to a tough place like this, you have to be a man. Stand up and do your job properly. The players know the importance of this game. I've been telling them all week... Smith was more hungry to win the ball."

Bowyer no doubt had also warned them about the careless concession of setpieces in the first place. Their clinical execution is clearly prioritised at Calmont Road and practice made perfect as early as the sixth minute after Jason Pearce's pointless foul on Jon Dadi Bodvarsson dangerously close to Charlton's penalty area. Shaun Williams' wicked delivery was headed home forcefully by Shaun Hutchinson at the far post. Sarr was again flatfooted but was probably no more culpable than a cadre of ball-watching colleagues.

Hutchinson's opening goal punished a disastrous start by Bowyer's men. Sarr had already hacked Wallace's shot off the line, with Phillips saving smartly from Mahlon Romeo's follow-up effort. But the visitors, encouraged by Josh Cullen's fearless example, recovered to control most of the action until the interval. Cullen was desperately unlucky when his shot beat Bartosz Bialkowski, cannoned off the underside of the bar but was scraped off the line by the startled keeper. Bialkowski performed heroically before the break when spectacularly tipping Macauley Bonne's thunderous volley over the bar, then getting down to turn away an effort from Darren Pratley, following fine approach play by Adam Matthews.

By now the better side, Charlton resumed their onslaught in the second half and drew level six minutes into the session. The Lions displayed similar vulnerability to setpieces when Cullen's inswinging left wing corner was scuffed clear only as far as Jonathan Leko, who found the top right corner from a difficult angle. His third goal of the season hardly compensated for a passive contribution from the WBA loanee.
Cullen continued to courageously carry the fight to the wilting Lions. He received sturdy support from Pratley and Conor Gallagher who, despite being singled out for early attention, with two fouls committed on him within the first minute, refused to be cowed. Up front, Bonne grafted gamely and Phillips seemed to have secured his side at least a point with a fine save from the excellent Ben Thompson's point-blank volley. But the late initiative and the points belonged with Millwall - as they have on 36 occasions since this one-sided fixture began at The Den on New Years Eve 1921. Plus ca change...

Millwall: Bialkowski, Romeo, Hutchinson, Cooper, M.Wallace, J.Wallace, Molumby, Williams, Thompson (O'Brien 86), Bradshaw (Smith 86), Bodvarsson (Mahoney 76). Not used: Steele,Ferguson, Pearce,Skalak.

Referee: Robert Jones. Att: 17,109 (2,211).

Fulham 2 (Cavaleiro 55, Mitrovic 63) Charlton 2 (Gallagher 41, Bonne 57).

Kevin Nolan reports from Craven Cottage.

Battered, bruised and brainweary, Charlton trudged off after this punishing, enthralling Thameside derby clutching a precious point. They had withstood a second half pounding from a wave of white-shirted attackers, ridden their luck at times but shown genuine character in clinging on to a share of the spoils. With four points quarried from an unholy trinity of recent games against Championship high flyers Leeds, Swansea City and Fulham, they had earned rest and recuperation during the second international break before tackling another daunting schedule featuring Derby County, Bristol City and West Bromwich Albion.

Not that the first lay-off worked in their favour; it disastrously cost them the services of top scorer Lyle Taylor, injured while on duty with Montserrat. There was brief alarm as the Addicks promptly lost to the modest likes of Birmingham City and Wigan Athletic; in Taylor's absence, in fact, they have picked up just four points from five games. But their spirited defiance at Craven Cottage, not to mention the ability and guts they showed, encourages hope that their mini-slide has been checked. They gave almost as good as they got, fought courageously and survived.

Among a catalogue of superb performances, the pick of which was a stupendous display of goalkeeping by Dillon Phillips, another more unlikely hero emerged. Taylor's injury has given Macauley Bonne an opportunity to step up from non-league football with Orient to the Championship with newly promoted Charlton. The massive leap in class proved initially tricky and the overawed tyro struggled to impress. Then the small matter of Charlton's winning goal against Leeds, which was claimed with a veteran's chutzpah by the newcomer despite only vague evidence it was his to own, changed his fortunes. Bonne had bravely thrown himself in where the boots were flying and, at the very least, forced defender Stuart Dallas to put through his own goal. The record book duly credits him with his first Charlton goal and nobody any longer disputes his right to it. Least of all Dallas.

Having made little impression on Swansea during midweek defeat at The Valley, Bonne came into his own against Fulham. He was significantly involved in the Addicks' first goal and brilliantly scored their second. His overall performance up front on his own, meanwhile, was accomplished and effective.

A first half during which Charlton held their own with Scott Parker's talented Cottagers was drawing to an entertaining close when Bonne cleverly nodded Phillips' long clearance on to Conor Gallagher, who instantly relayed the ball to Jake Forster-Caskey near the left touchline. Stepping inside to cross right-footed, the wide midfielder picked out Chris Solly closing in at the far post. Solly's canny header was cushioned perfectly for Gallagher, intelligently on the move as usual, to half-volley past Marcus Bettinelli. Five players had contributed to a fine team goal.

No doubt irritated to find themselves behind at the interval, Fulham took steps to redress the situation. Inspired substitute Bobby Decordova-Reid was immediately dangerous, his sharp exchange of passes with Ivan Cavaleiro outwitting the attentions of Forster-Caskey and Naby Sarr and sending the electric-heeled Portuguese winger through to beat Phillips with a blistering 25-yard strike.
Fulham's equality lasted just two minutes, the time it took Bonne to put the visitors in front again. Josh Cullen's right wing corner was scuffed clear for Jonny Williams to re-cycle possession to Darren Pratley on the left. The wily campaigner switched feet and crossed for Bonne to climb above Aleksandar Mitrovic and flight a deft header over Bettinelli and sweetly under the bar. This goal had "Bonne" indelibly stamped on it.

Again Charlton's lead was shortlived. After Joe Bryan and Mitrovic had each rattled the crossbar, the bustling Serb drew Fulham level again under frankly dubious circumstances. Returning from an offside position as Phillips brilliantly saved Tom Cairney's diving header, Mitrovic re-joined the action, turned and bullied a second equaliser over the fallen keeper. Neither referee Keith Stroud nor his equally myopic assistant were interested in Charlton's protests.

A riproaring, rumbustious game now seemed Fulham's - and especially Decordova-Reid's - for the taking but Phillips had other ideas. Two wonderful saves from the Jamaican flyer, first from a point-blank header, then a corner-bound curler, were mere tasters for the frankly incredible block on the goalline which kept out Decordova-Reid's sure thing in added time. His save defies description so none will be offered here, except to point out that goalkeepers hear a different drummer and are often not accountable for their actions. Many of them are not all there but Dillon was the coolest customer inside Craven Cottage on Saturday. Anyway, I can't talk. I swore in fluent Hungarian when the added time board showed seven extra minutes, then broke into a fit of hysterical giggling when they were over. See you after the break if they let me out in time...

Fulham: Bettinelli, Mason, Johansen (Onomah 97), Ream, Sessegnon (Decordova-Reid 46), Bryan, Cairney, Arter (Reed 46), Knockaert, Cavaleiro, Mitrovic. Not used: Rodak, Odoi, Le Marchand, Kamara. Booked: Bryan, Mitrovic.

Booked: Gallagher. Referee: Keith Stroud. Att: 18,654 (1,970 visiting).